Matthew 25:31-46 (Last Sunday)
St. John, Galveston 11/22/2026
“Bad” Sheep and “Good” Goats
Rev. Alan Taylor

+ In Nomine Jesu +

    A man was walking on the beach one day and he found a magic lamp.  He picked it up and rubbed it. A genie appeared and told him he would be granted one wish. Apparently, this genie was forced to cut back on the allotment of wishes due to tough economic times.  At any rate, the man was given one wish. He thought about it for moment and then asked for a copy of the newspaper with the stock market report that would be published one year from that day. Suddenly the paper was in his hands and the genie disappeared. With greedy eyes the man scanned the columns of the paper and identified stocks in which he could invest and make millions of dollars.  Pleased with himself and his shrewd plan, he turned the page of the paper only to find his own obituary.  

    Obviously the story is fictitious but, it serves a purpose for this morning's message, as we consider the Gospel reading from Matthew 25.  The passage is about Jesus’ coming in judgment, at which time He will separate the sheep from the goats, believers from unbelievers. Scripture says elsewhere that Jesus will come “like a thief in the night.” In other words, the day and the hour of His return are unknown, consequently, we are warned that, “Today is the appointed day.Today is the day of salvation.”  

    In time, Jesus will descend from heaven with “the shout of the archangel and with the sound of the trumpet of God.” Delight will fill the hearts of the faithful, while the unfaithful will be racked with fear. He will separate the sheep from the goats. The sheep on His right hand and the goats on His left.

    Having separated the sheep from the goats, Jesus then recounts all of the good done by the sheep and all of the evil done by the goats. As He says, His sheep fed the hungry, they gave a drink to the thirsty and they clothed the naked. Conversely, the goats did none of the same. Consequently, Jesus says to them “depart from Me, you cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the devil and his angels.”  

    While it is clear that there is a definite separation between the sheep and the goats, the holy and the unholy, sin causes the sheep to sometimes fear that they may be “bad” sheep, and the goats to assume that they are “good” goats. In other words, the sheep recognize all of the bad things they’ve done in life and they sometimes fear that those things will be brought up on the Day of Judgment. The goats, on the other hand, assume that every act they carried out in life with a seeming sense of virtue will be counted to their credit on the Day of Judgment.    

    In reality, if you look closely at the text from Matthew 25, you’ll find that Jesus commends the sheep, that is, He has only good to say to them and about them, nothing contrary.  On the other hand, He condemns the goats, having nothing good to say to them or about them.

    Somewhere in our DNA we have had imprinted there the notion that God will judge the world on the last day with sort of a two column ledger system. One column for all the good we’ve done and another column for all the bad. Deep within our psyche is this notion that as long as the good column is longer than the bad, we’ll be O.K. Consequently it’s sort of natural for us to think in terms of “bad” sheep and “good” goats.      

    Our perception, however, couldn’t be farther from the truth. Again, Scripture tells us exactly what the Day of Judgment will be like. Jesus will come and separate the sheep from the goats. On what criteria? Well, on the basis of faith in Christ. For "you are saved by grace, through faith." Goats are goats because, in life, they denied the grace and mercy of God in Christ.  Consequently, they stand before God, naked, as it were, in the unfettered corruption of their flesh. Every supposed good they had done in life is counted as sin against them because they were so proud as to assume that they could impress God by their works. While they hoped there would be that two sided ledger of good and bad, there is only the bad. Everything is known about their life and everything is wrong. They had trusted in themselves and they are found, most decidedly, wanting.  

    Conversely, sheep are sheep by virtue of their trust in and their dependence on Christ who, throughout life, called them by name and spoke to them through His Word.  They are sheep because they hear Him say, “I have called you by name.  You are mine.”  They are sheep because they hear Him say, “I have loved you unto death, even death on a cross.”  They are sheep because they hear Him say, “Take and drink, this is My blood, shed for you for the forgiveness of sins.”  They are sheep because there are few words more meaningful to them than God’s Word of absolution.  “I forgive you all of your sins!”  They are sheep because, their sins have been washed away in the blood of the Lamb.

    When the sheep, when you stand before God on the Day of Judgment, He will commend you for the good done throughout your life because He fills your life with good things. Your life is sanctified, made holy, through the faith that you have in Christ. Whether you are feeding the hungry, working a job and providing for your family, loving your spouse and your children, or, simply being a friend to someone else, He says, “WELL DONE.” It’s all good because it is done through faith in Jesus Christ.  

    But, Pastor, we say, what about my sins!? What about all those times when I didn’t feed the hungry, when I didn’t extend a hand of compassion to someone who needed it? What about those times, I’m ashamed to say, when I was angry with God, or when I failed to thank Him for all of His goodness to me? What about those times when I took His grace for granted or, when I confessed my sin, and committed the same sin yet again? Well, I would challenge you to show me in this morning's Gospel reading, in which verse are the sins of the sheep brought up against them.    

    There is an old legend about Martin Luther's namesake, a man named Martin of Tours. As the story goes, Martin was at home one day when there came a knock at his door. He answered it, and there was a man standing there who claimed to be Jesus. Martin suspected that the man might actually be the devil, the angel of darkness, who had come to tempt him. Martin decided that he would put the man to the test. So, he asked him, what sin most often grips me, such that I have had to confess to you over and over again? Without hesitation the man at the door said, “I don’t remember!” At which time, Martin welcomed His Lord into his home.              

    On the Day of Judgment Jesus will not remember your sins. That whole side of the supposed ledger will have been washed away in the crimson flow of Jesus' blood.  More than that, you will be astonished by all of the good that God brought forth from your life.  

“See, the Lamb, so long expected, 
Comes with pardon down from heaven.
Let us haste, with tears of sorrow,
One and all, to be forgiven.”

“So, when next He comes in glory
And the world is wrapped in fear,
He will shield us with His mercy
And with words of love draw near.”  
(LSB #345 v. 3&4)

In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit. Amen.

The peace of God that passes all understanding keep your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus unto life everlasting.  Amen.

+ Soli Deo Gloria +